Skip to content

menu

HomeAboutServicesContact
Gray Reed logo

Energy & the Law

Contract Disputes

Subscribe to Contract Disputes

Winter Storm Uri – No Summary Judgment This Time

By Charles Sartain on September 13, 2023
Posted in Contract Disputes, operations

Unit Petroleum Company v. Koch Energy Services, LLC is another force majeure case arising out of winter storm Uri. Unlike a similar case, summary judgment was denied because, said the United States District Court,

The word “reasonable”, although not ambiguous, is a question of fact that must be answered by looking into the circumstances of…

Who Owns Produced Water in Texas?

By Charles Sartain on September 4, 2023
Posted in Contract Disputes, Hydraulic Fracturing, Land Titles
Co-author Stephen A. Cooney

In Cactus Water Services LLC v. COG Operating, LLC., a divided Texas court of appeals answered the question this way: The oil and gas producer prevails over the purchaser of the surface owner’s right to own and sell produced water.

The majority discussed the composition of produced water. To…

“Harmony” in a Texas Mineral Reservation

By Charles Sartain on August 9, 2023
Posted in Contract Disputes, Land Titles

In Smart v. 3039 RNC Holdings LLC, the court reminds us that it will harmonize all parts of a contract, even one that “is not a model of clarity”, to reach the correct result.

RNC owned the surface and 50% of the mineral estate in a 45.6 acre tract in Karnes County. RNC agreed…

Supreme Court of Texas Tackles the Meaning of “Predecessors”

By Charles Sartain on July 31, 2023
Posted in Contract Disputes, Title Issues

The plain, ordinary, and generally accepted meaning of a word doesn’t mean “anything goes”. It depends on context, says the Supreme Court of Texas in Finley Resources Inc. v.  Headington Royalty Inc., a dispute over the meaning of “predecessors”. For the underlying facts see our post on the court of appeals decision.

The release…

Appeals Court Revives Lessor’s Fraud Claims

By Charles Sartain on June 6, 2023
Posted in Contract Disputes

Co-author Blake Bryan *

Tips on litigation avoidance: Not making promises you don’t intend to keep is easy enough. Stating a fact or making a promise and things change, you could be a fraudster if you don’t come clean before closing.That’s the takeaway in Baxsto, LLC v. Roxo Energy Co., a Texas Court of Appeals…

Texas Supreme Court Decides Arbitrability of Offshore Agreements

By Charles Sartain on May 2, 2023
Posted in Contract Disputes, Operating Agreements

In TotalEnergies E&P USA, Inc. v. MP Gulf of Mexico LLC. the Supreme Court of Texas resolved the chaos created by conflicting dispute resolution regimes in three contracts for ownership and operation of an offshore unit and gathering system. The essential question: Did the parties agree that an arbitrator, rather than the courts…

Insurance Coverage Not Limited by a Texas Service Agreement

By Charles Sartain on April 18, 2023
Posted in Contract Disputes

As you negotiate your master service agreements are you confident that you know how insurance choices might affect indemnity obligations? Me neither. That’s why I turn to my Gray Reed partner Darin Brooks and his insurance coverage lawyers. I didn’t consult them about this post so all errors are on me, not them.

A basic…

More Force Majeure Fallout From Uri

By Charles Sartain on April 6, 2023
Posted in Contract Disputes

MIECO, LLC v. Pioneer Natural Resources presented a challenge to a force majeure defense in a dispute arising from Winter Storm Uri. The defense carried the day.

MIECO agreed to purchase 20,000 MMBtu/day of natural gas from Pioneer. Pioneer delivered residue gas from the tailgate of a Targa processing plant to two points near the…

Texas Supreme Court Rules on “Bespoke” Add-Back Royalty Clause

By Charles Sartain on March 16, 2023
Posted in Contract Disputes, Lease Disputes

In Devon Energy Production Company, LP et al v. Sheppard et al, the Supreme Court of Texas construed what it referred to as a “bespoke” and “highly unique” royalty clause in several oil and gas leases to prohibit the producers from deducting out of the lessor’s royalty post-production costs incurred downstream of the point of…

Long-Running Texas Boundary Dispute Continues

By Charles Sartain on March 1, 2023
Posted in Contract Disputes, Land Titles, Title Issues

Co-author Travis Nadilini

Ellison v. Three Rivers Acquisition LLC et al., on remand from the Texas Supreme Court, is the third round of a boundary dispute between mineral lessees in Irion County.  

For the history of Ms. Ellison’s odyssey from court to court to court, see our 2019 post discussing the first Court…

Post navigation

Older Posts 

About Charles Sartain

I have been helping clients of all types resolve their commercial disputes for most of my 35 years as a lawyer. Of the many industries in which I have worked, the energy business is the most fascinating…More

Stay Connected

Subscribe to this blog via RSS Charles Sartain on Linkedin

Topics

Archives

Recent Posts

  • What Makes a Reservation a Mineral Interest and not a Royalty?
  • Winter Storm Uri – No Summary Judgment This Time
  • Texas Landowner Enjoined from Interfering with Lessee’s Operations
  • Who Owns Produced Water in Texas?
  • Will the Fixed or Floating Suits Ever End?

Gray Reed Blogs

  • Tilting The Scales
  • M&A Insights
  • Texas Construction Law Blog
  • Texas Employer Handbook
  • Texas Tax Talk

Energy & the Law

Gray Reed logo
Subscribe to this blog via RSS Charles Sartain on Linkedin
Privacy PolicyDisclaimer

About Our Firm

A full-service Texas law firm with offices in Dallas, Houston and Waco, Gray Reed provides legal services to companies ranging from start-up to Fortune 500 as well as high net worth individuals. Gray Reed attorneys assist clients with a myriad of legal issues including commercial litigation, corporate transactions, oil and gas, tax planning and litigation, real estate, construction, healthcare, trusts and estates, employment law, family law, intellectual property and bankruptcy. For more information, visit www.grayreed.com.

Read More...
Copyright © 2023, Gray Reed All Rights Reserved.
Law blog design & platform by LexBlog LexBlog Logo